Bloggers and influencers have become an integral component of information sourcing across East Africa. The public uses blogs, privately run websites and social networks to crowdsource information from social networks, which they then publish and distribute. But it’s not all rosy for this group of content makers.
Bloggers are known for publishing information that mainstream media outlets would rather ignore. In some countries, they have become trusted defenders of freedom of expression and the public’s only way of accessing and consuming content that corporates, politicians and governments often suppress.
Perhaps because of the increasing trust in these alternative sources of information, bloggers, influencers, information activists, and owners of digital platforms in the region are constantly in trouble with the law. Every other week, they face arrests for publishing articles or videos deemed critical of the government. In extreme circumstances, authorities have shut down some of their platforms for leaking corruption scandals.
Trouble with the law
Media watchdogs often accuse bloggers and influencers of lacking quality control. They are also faulted for having limited information verification mechanisms, sharing fake or false information, sensitive documents and information (security-wise), or leaking intimate images of celebrities.
Since most bloggers are not trained journalists, they have also gained the reputation of breaking ethical rules of citizen journalism, including publishing biased reports, obtaining information by nefarious means, publishing indecent content and in some cases, extortion. All of which is contrary to journalistic expectations.
In Kenya, for instance, blogger, activist and influencer Mwalimu Mutemi Wa Kiama,48, who runs Edwin Kiama – The Wanjiku Revolution Movement has twice been arrested by the Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) over items he posted on social media.
To boot, he has a lot of following online, 59, 158 followers on Twitter and 31, 613 on Facebook meaning his content gets a lot.
“In the first instance, it was alleged that I altered the cover of Peter Kagwanja’s book on President Uhuru Kenyatta’s legacy. I think the real reason was a thread I had retweeted on colonial chiefs and the positions their children and grandchildren occupy in our society today,” Mutemi explains.
“The second time I was arrested, I was accused of creating a poster asking the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to stop giving loans to President Uhuru Kenyatta.”
Mutemi says he knows why bloggers and influencers are constantly arrested and harassed (more than mainstream media practitioners).
“We go where the mainstream media won’t. I am always prepared to speak truth to power once I have verified that the information I am sharing is factual despite the threat of legal action,” the blogger said, adding that he focuses on advocacy issues around social justice, social accountability and human rights.
“In the civil society sector we have organizations such as Defenders’ Coalition, Katiba Institute, Kituo Cha Sheria, Kenya Human Rights Commission, Kenya National Commission on Human Rights, Article 19 of the constitution and others who are ready to provide legal support for activists. Regular bloggers don’t have these.”
Bloggers are a constant target
Influential government officials, corporates with secrets, and powerful individuals who bloggers and influencers have spoken out against are known to use their money and influence to criminalize the actions of bloggers and influencers. Sometimes, this happens in cases where bloggers and influencers have not broken any laws.
Jamii Forums is Tanzania’s most popular information site. It advocates for digital rights, freedom of expression, accountability and human rights. The platform is known across the globe for two things: its online channel (Jamii Forums) that publishes crowdsourced information, and its director Maxence Melo who has been arrested more times than he can count, including in 2016 and 2008.
Melo and his co-founders started Jamii Forums in 2003 to provide a platform for the public to ‘breathe’. At the time, information sources in Tanzania were mainly media houses, but bloggers and outlets such as Jamii Forums soon joined in.
However, most Tanzanian bloggers were threatened into silence by the previous regime (led by the late President John Pombe Magufuli). Those who remain vocal to date are branded agents of Western imperialists.
The situation has slightly improved under the current administration of President Samia Suluhu Hassan. She has opened up space for people to air their views. According to Melo, social media has become a crucial source of information in the country and is probably trusted more than mainstream media outlets.
Jamii Forums boasts ministers, MPs, local politicians and millions of citizens as members. They regularly hold serious discussions, share news and are used by the public to expose government and corporate corruption anonymously.
The forum’s first national impact came in 2008 after a whistle-blower exposed a major corruption scandal. (Back then, it was known as Jambo Forums). The Richmond Energy deal corruption scandal led to the resignation of the former Prime Minister of Tanzania, Edward Lowassa, followed by the dissolution of the cabinet. Melo, who until that time had been running the site anonymously, was tracked and arrested.
In 2019, Melo was awarded the CPJ International Press Freedom Award. But he prefers to call himself an information architect or information activist. He says Jamii Forums has a legal department, and they have trained the team at the platform to understand cyberspace and its laws. When a citizen publishes any content on the site, the Jamii Forums team fact-checks it and verifies its authenticity. This is done in line with Jamii Forums’ editorial policy and the public engagement guidelines.
What bloggers and influencers need to know
According to Melo, many bloggers and influencers do not know their rights when they get arrested or interrogated. “As Jamii Forums, we are currently pursuing a new tact in fighting for digital rights in the country,” Melo says.
“We have decided to engage the judiciary to help them understand cyberspace well to appreciate why it matters and protect digital citizens (netizens).” He added that they had done this for the past two years. “We see the judiciary handling cybercrime cases differently.”
Emily Kinama, a research and litigation associate at Katiba Institute (in Kenya) and an Advocate of the High Court of Kenya, concurs with Melo’s sentiments. She, however, warns about the need for bloggers to know the legal implications of what they publish.
“A person who knowingly publishes information that is false in print, broadcast, data or over a computer system, that is calculated or results in panic, chaos, or violence among citizens of the republic, or which is likely to discredit the reputation of a person commits an offence and shall on conviction, be liable to a fine not exceeding five million shillings or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding ten years, or to both,” she says, adding that these are covered under ‘The Computer Misuse and Cyber Crimes Act’ in Kenya.
But what exactly do bloggers and influencers need to know about data protection laws (in Kenya) regarding government institutions / public service officials and corporate, private citizens?
“Generally, they should have an understanding of the Data Protection Act, which is an Act of Parliament to give effect to Article 31(c) and (d) of the Constitution to establish the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner; to make provision for the regulation of the processing of personal data; to provide for the rights of data subjects and obligations of data controllers and processors, and connected purposes. In addition, they should understand the definitions of the different stakeholders regarding data protection as well as their rights, duties and obligations of the different players,” Emily Kinama explained in an email.
She says that journalism trainers should teach the basics of reporting ethics to bloggers and influencers. That issues such as protecting children’s identity when reporting child-related content or dealing with graphic images from tragedies like terror attacks should be clear to them.
And when it comes to revealing personal/ intimate details of people’s lives, she insists that bloggers need to know that the Data Protection Act is in place to protect people’s privacy. She also stressed the importance of bloggers understanding which materials they are allowed to use and which affect or infringe on people’s privacy.
Blogging in ‘undemocratic’ spaces
In Uganda, Henry Ndugwa, 51, a blogger with over 98,000 followers on Facebook who has never had any problem with the law, shares his secret; “I have not faced any legal challenges because I make sure I follow the laws in the course of my duty,” Ndugwa says.
“While I may go against Uganda Communications Commission censorship, I always make sure I have credible information just in case anyone opts to drag me to court.”
His blog, Kakensa Media is equally popular but is well aware of the environment bloggers in Uganda operate.
“I know we face a very big challenge of working under an undemocratic environment,” the Ugandan blogger admits. “We participate in civic education, but this comes at a price because most bloggers and influencers in the country do get arrested now and then.”
He says that Uganda’s general press freedom has declined drastically in the past ten years due to the continuous persecution and harassment of writers, journalists, and bloggers.
“I can’t travel to Uganda frequently (he is based abroad) the way I used to do before I started writing about politics. But, having seen other writers being persecuted, I also fear for my life.”
The hate speech trap
One of the main pitfalls that bloggers and influencers fall into is sharing hate speech spoken by politicians. The other is reproducing or plagiarizing work created by others. Liz Lenjo, an advocate of the High Court of Kenya and a Managing Consultant at MyIP Legal Studio, says bloggers who do this open themselves up to be held responsible for spreading hate speech.
“They need to attend trainings and residencies that empower journalists and bloggers,” Lenjo says. “Through these trainings, they can be exposed to other potential business models in the media business.” She advises bloggers to find authors or creators of content if they would like to use it. “Seek permission in the form of a license. It must be in writing regardless of it being free.”
For the media to flourish, and the society to have free flow of accurate and verifiable information, journalists, the drivers in the passing of information are expected to be well grounded in laws and the legal aspect pertaining to the job, writes Alfred Ganzo.
Pitching provides numerous opportunities for your new or existing business ideas to be discovered and realized; and as Simon Mtabazi writes, some startups have become billion-dollar companies due to efffevie pitches
The success you achieve with your media startup business will heavily rely on your reputation as a trustworthy company, and as Nandi Mwiyombella writes, it will also open a new window for customers and potential investors.
That’s why I think today is such a great space for us to sit back and reflect on the questions that could help us shape the kind of journalism that we want to see in our local and global community.
The report specifically analysed eight major variables which include: newsroom structure and resources, media ownership and business models, organisational capacity, innovation culture, journalism culture, financial trends and results, content quality and COVID-19.
Mudi, in her role as Media Council of Kenya regional coordinator in charge of Mombasa(covering the entire coastal region), has found herself at the forefront in advocating and fighting to protect journalists’ rights, culminating in her being awarded for her peace efforts in the run-up and during the 2022 general elections in Kenya.
The 2022 general elections have been mentally draining for journalists, some of whom have had to stay on the campaign trail for over a year. Others have had to toy with the tough call of managing teams in the newsroom. East Site’s Isaac Swila and political writer Rawlings Otieno recount their experiences
What role did social media influencers play in the election? What voice did they give in political discourses during and around the election period? And to what extent did political candidates involve the influencers in marketing their manifestos to sway votes in their favour? East Site writer Steven Omondi unpacks the details
The media industry is experiencing enormous transformation as new digital trends emerge. With the vast opportunities that the digital space offers, media owners and content producers must deliberately adapt to how the audience consumes content.
With the increased Digital Technology at the palm of just anybody; there are a lot of information that distort whether deliberately or not highlighting the need of robust Fact0checking as Asha D. Abinallah explains
Is there a danger in media personalities having a vibrant social media presence? Assuming they have a massive media following, should they self-regulate and filter what they post? And when they engage with followers, should their opinions be taken as personal, or does it represent the journalist’s media house? East Site writer Isaac Swila explores
Media stakeholders are raising concerns over the lack of gender-inclusive reporting in East African newsrooms. They want concerted efforts to ensure more female journalists get equal opportunities like their male counterparts.
The partnership will also ensure that local content is curated and distributed to better optimize the product and meet the needs of Kenyan online users.
The news industry is constantly changing, and in the last few years, User Generated Content (UGC) has become a ubiquitous feature in news sourcing and packaging. However, media houses and journalists need to establish verification and credibility safeguards to avoid the misinformation trap.
Reporting on elections is, for many journalists, an opportunity to establish themselves as reliable political reporters. But the task comes with certain risks, particularly in the East African sub-region.
Stakeholders are now calling for concerted efforts, better planning and preparations for journalists before they are sent out on the field to cover Kenya’s high-stakes August 9 General Elections.
East Africa’s media grapples with a myriad of challenges whenever general elections approach. Not only do editors struggle with balancing the competing political interests, at times at the altar of professionalism, but individual journalists pay dearly, many suffering attacks in the course of their duties.
As Form One students settle into a new life in secondary school, this has also been a period of reflection. We have read tear-jerking and heart-warming stories of determined students who overcame many odds to get an education and how well-wishers came together in their aid.
There is renewed optimism in the Tanzanian media space following the ascension to power of President Samia Suluhu whose regime is keen to relax some of the laws deemed punitive to journalists and media houses
Uganda fell behind, whereas Kenya improved its press freedom ranking in the Reporters Without Borders 2022 Press Freedom Index. And after years of media freedom decline, Tanzania appears to be on the right track. But overall, media freedom activists say there is still work to be done.
A free and independent press is the cornerstone of any democracy and the foundation of economic success, mostly because through our free press, we’re able to hold the leadership to account.
To align with the changing times and stay relevant in the business, media houses are challenged to rethink their strategy and to adopt and understand obstacles and challenges they face towards rethinking and exploring alternative sources of revenue and on developing the digital strategy.
A team of young, Tanzanian tech-savvy communication professionals is dreaming big. It seeks to usher a new dawn in media business management in Tanzania by optimising employee output and offering consultancy to media businesses on how they can operate with a minimal budget but still attain their goals.
The chances of meeting a medical graduate practising journalism are usually very slim, especially in Sub-Saharan Africa. But two Tanzanian physicians have broken away from that norm by inventing a start-up called Afyatoon. It uses visual art technology to tell compelling medical stories. They narrate to the EAST Site their experience and share their vision for the future.
Did you know that in 2021 Kenyans watched less TV and spent more time on social media? Or that some Kenyans rely on family, friends, or even social media icons and bloggers as a source of news and information? These are some of the conclusions highlighted in the 2021 State of the Media Survey conducted by the Media Council of Kenya (MCK).
The effects of the Covid pandemic continue to change the world in ways we had not imagined possible. The media is going through a painful transformation to keep up with changing production, distribution and consumption habits. In East Africa, Uganda’s Media Challenge Initiative (MCI) recently hosted a panel discussion on Media Viability comprising experienced journalists from Television, Radio, Print and Online/Digital media to address lessons learned from the pandemic. East Site’s Moses Mutente attended the panel and compiled this article.
In this commentary, Uganda-based journalist Caleb Okereke shares deep personal insights into why media schools in East Africa must rethink their curriculum. He stresses the need for trainers to begin teaching media ownership to better equip journalism students for the dynamic and cutthroat job market by taking us through his journey as a journalism student and media owner.
For the second year running, a survey commissioned by the Media Council of Kenya shows that the trust level in Kenyan media has nosedived, raising fundamental questions on how media will play its watchdog role more so with landmark elections set for August 9. EAST Site writer Isaac Swila explores.
Legacy media is currently caught between a rock and a hard place — the Covid pandemic and the rise and proliferation of social media has hit revenues hard. Some say this could signal the end of news as we used to know it. However, Ugandan decorated journalist Ernest Bazanye believes the industry will survive and thrive, but not without a fight.
Free media is often described as the fourth estate, the gatekeeper, the whistleblower, and many more. American singer Jim Morrison once said, “whoever controls the media, controls the mind.” No wonder governments worldwide try hard to control the press. But the media itself, particularly in Uganda, faces a severe identity crisis that requires urgent action, writes guest commentator Jimmy Spire Ssentongo.
World over, disinformation is a virus that continues to permeate newsrooms giving media managers and journalists a headache on how to deal with it. Dr. Myriam Redondo, a newsroom trainer in digital verification and associate professor in International Relations (PhD) explains how to tackle the virus in an engagement with EAST Site writer Isaac Swila.